Open Enrollment | Subscribe to Book Business HERE
Follow us on

Learning to Adapt

Disruptive technology has been a source of major upheaval in the education publishing industry. However, many expect a bright future, as publishers and startups alike hope to seize the massive opportunities presented by data-driven, adaptive learning.

October 2013 By Denis Wilson
Get the Flash Player to see this rotator.

Kirshner says that while the economy certainly has played a role in industry woes, the introduction of new technology in the last ten years has been the most profound agent of change, and those that make the wisest investments in technology will come out on top. "All of us, if we're honest about it, are learning about [technology]. The science behind how people learn is becoming a big part of our business."

In many ways, the technology that has been a source of major disruption is also a massive opportunity for publishers, although with a number of caveats, says Chris Goodson, senior vice president of services innovation at HMH. "We understand it's not a panacea. There's a lot of noise around what technology can do. There's still the [problem] of access and adoption. There are a lot of places without enough bandwidth."

Considering the User: A Smarter Future

Though these outside forces are factors, Lynch feels that some onus should be placed on a paradigm that exists within the industry where the end user is insufficiently considered. In many ways, textbooks, especially in higher education, have not met the needs of students, says Lynch. "I think the reason is K-12 and higher education publishers don't think of their customer in the same way as people who make cars or make jewelry do. They build a product for the decision maker, rather than the user, kind of like dog food."

Kirshner has seen that old paradigm begin to shift: "I think our industry is very focused on the student and the learner and that' s the biggest development…we are much more tied to the results that our products bring than ever before."

To that end, much emerging technology is geared toward enhancing the efficacy of publishers' products. Through the use of big data analysis, tech firms are attempting to reinvent the current education model. There are a lot of terms thrown around—adaptive, personalized, data-driven—but at heart it is the pursuit of tools that learn how a given student learns and follows them through their development.

Knewton is one such adaptive learning firm, and has partnered with the likes of Pearson, Cengage, and HMH. The company has built a platform for publishers to deploy educational applications, rather than building the applications themselves, says Knewton COO, David Liu. "We're building the data infrastructure for proficiency predictions and recommendations. We're not building the middle school algebra application. We're gonna power that. We're the Intel inside."

Liu says that personalization is disrupting the entire education sector, and that Knewton benefits from partnering with large publishers because together, they can gather a massive amount of data on student learning. Liu cites the partnership with HMH, which has a huge share of the K-12 market. "If you just look at the reach of that, the students that will take the math courses powered by Knewton, you're going to see the promise of this longitudinal personalization taking hold."

The drawback of the current education model—as it's been throughout history—is that you are "literally an unknown entity when you step into a course," says Liu. Adaptive learning allows for the level of proficiency a student demonstrates in a math course to be applied to science courses, making the experience more relevant to each student. Knewton's approach is intended to serve an individual throughout their development, from K-12 (or earlier) on through professional training or career changes.

Liu says that a lot of companies are coming around to technology—not only willing, but aggressively moving in that direction—and that adaptive learning is no longer a question. "Every application that they build in education, whether startup or established, will be adaptive."

Kirshner agrees that data analysis will lead to a more productive experience for teachers and students. “Technology is not a matter of turning on a computer and looking at a screen,” says Kirshner. “Personalized and adaptive learning are going to be part of the future. Any company in the industry should be thinking about ways to personalize the experience. The more data we all can collect and analyze, the better it is going to be for the student.”

This is essentially what powers Knewton: the company has a team of data scientists and software engineers in which it has heavily invested and which allows it to harness the power of "big data." This is not a core competency for most publishers. "We're getting feedback from Pearson, others, saying it's very difficult for us to do this," says Lui.

Liu feels that publishers should seriously consider where a partner can do something better than they can do on their own. "In a lot of the discussions we're having with publishing houses, they all say, 'Why shouldn't we do this in-house?' Then they all go through that process, whether it's six months or a year." In the end, it can be very costly experimentation, says Lui. "Their core competency is instructional design and education content development. I think the content is better than anything you'll see from the open education resource movement. What the publishers do incredibly well is organize this content to deliver an outcome."

Publishers should look at themselves as content producers rather than textbook makers, says Lynch, VP of publishing strategy at Finitiv Corporation. "Publishers know how to make content. Publishers' talent is working with authors, which is a significant competency. Taking lots of information and consolidating it and writing it and reinterpreting it with context and in a meaningful context, and adding to that a pedagogical structure so you can learn from it—that's what they do. It makes no difference how it's delivered."

A tipping point in favor of adaptive, data-driven learning is inevitable, says Liu, and that adaptive tools will eventually eclipse old product lines—namely, textbooks. Those that manage down the old revenue streams while pursuing the new are going to become the winners, says Liu. "I believe in the future it will all be data driven and competency based."

If the future of learning is in fact adaptive and data-driven, then one sign of the times was the acquisition of adaptive learning technology firm Aleks Corporation by McGraw-Hill Education in June of this year.

Looking Forward

One of the healthy benefits of a more personalized approach to learning for students is that publishers have been prompted to reorient their products toward the end user—long a hallmark of the technology sector. Some also see technology as a trigger for a more holistic approach to student learning. "It would be my hope that those of us in this industry stop having lines that divide our K-12 and higher education operations," says Kirshner of Cengage Learning. "I think, more and more, as we look at the students themselves, we're going to see more cross-pollination between these groups."

However, the path to the future is by no means unhindered. Although technology is empowering the sector, it faces obstacles of access to and adoption of technology. Public institutions have a lot of big decisions about where money is spent in order to explore technological solutions to education, says Kirshner, whether it's the devices students use or making sure schools have sufficient broadband access.

Lynch agrees: "To me the challenge for publishers, is how do I develop tools, content and methodology that can improve the teaching and learning in large public schools in urban areas? And from a business perspective, that's where the students are."

In some regards, higher education has led the way when it comes to technology. "K12 has been on the sideline," says Lynch, "because of the lack of access to computers and handheld devices in this country. It's hard to have a consistent approach to the use of digital technology." In higher education, students are able to approach learning more independently, bring their own devices, and on most domestic campuses, have access to the internet.

However, Goodson from HMH says it's important for publishers to find learners where they are and understand the channels they use to find content. In some cases, textbooks are still the best way to reach students. "We want to give every student equal chance to consume our content in some way. You hate to see technology as a divider."



Click here to leave a comment...
Comment *
Most Recent Comments:




<i>"Despite news to the contrary — especially from the social media space — reports of the death of email are greatly exaggerated. In fact, as your inboxes most likely show, email is growing and becoming even more sophisticated."</i> -- from <i>The Ultimate Guide to Email Marketing</i> 

It's true. Email marketing is still going strong, and continues to be one of the most important factors in any marketing campaign. 

From the first six months of 2010 to the first six months of 2011 alone, there was a nearly 21 percent increase in email volume! The average number of emails received per day in the first six months of 2010 was 472, and during the first six months of 2011, the daily average increased to 571. Marketers are having success with their email campaigns and using it more and more.

That being the case, your email marketing campaign needs all the attention it can get, and knowing what works and what doesn't is the best way to start. That's where "The Ultimate Guide to Email Marketing" comes in. 

The Guide is brought to you by the email marketing experts at DMIQ and their extensive research into one of the largest email campaign archives in the industry. On top of latest trends, it features 19 best practice chapters from today's email marketing thought leaders. You will learn how to create a relevant email program to nurture leads and drive sales, how to best use call-to-action visuals in your emails, and how to use social email to improve marketing effectiveness.

You’ll also learn:

•	Email Marketing Trends in 2011
•	Best Practices in Writing Subject Lines
•	The Strategy (and Tricks) for Improving Open Rate and Response
•	6 Tests to Improve Email Program Results
•	5 Best Practices for the Gangbusting Email Campaign
•	Best Practices for Improving Email Performance
•	6 Ways to Make Your Emails Mobile-Ready
•	Email Branding — The 16 Most Effective Strategies
•	11 Best Creative Practices for B-to-B Email Marketing
•	The Keys to Developing a Successful E-newsletter
•	How to Determine Your Customers’ Email Content Tolerance
•	How Email Marketers Can Optimize the Social Media Opportunity
•	…Just to name a few!

This comprehensive report also offers three in-depth case studies, so you can see practical examples of how these methods worked for real-life businesses. "The Ultimate Guide to Email Marketing" is an essential tool for any business that ever sends an email. 

<b><u>100% Money-Back Guarantee</b></u>

Your order is risk-free. If you are not completely delighted with “The Ultimate Guide to Email Marketing,” notify us within 30 days for a complete credit or refund, no questions asked.

<u>About DirectMarketingIQ</u>
The Research Division of the Target Marketing Group, DirectMarketingIQ ( is the go-to resource for direct marketers. Publishing books, special reports, case study stockpiles and how-to guides, it opens up a new world for those who seek more information, more ideas and more success stories in order to boost their own marketing efforts. DirectMarketingIQ has unparalleled access to direct marketing data - including the world's most complete library of direct mail as well as a growing library of promotional emails across hundreds of categories - and proudly produces content from the most experienced editors and practitioners in the industry.

Note: You must have Adobe Acrobat Reader in order to read The Ultimate Guide to Email Marketing, which is in PDF format. The Ultimate Guide to Email Marketing

PDF FORMAT "Despite news to the contrary — especially from the social media space — reports of the death of email are greatly exaggerated. In fact, as your inboxes most likely show, email is growing and becoming even more sophisticated." -- from The Ultimate Guide to Email Marketing It's true....


Available as a PDF.<BR> <BR>In these challenging economic times, get access to powerful statistical evidence to fortify your decisions and justify your expenditures! <BR><BR><EM>The Power of Direct Marketing</EM> provides top-line comprehensive analyses and forecasts from the DMA/Global Insight economic model on the impact of direct marketing across all industries and sectors of the economy.<BR> <BR>Emphasis on Short-Term Forecasts! Recognizing that many businesses need to plan for the coming year, included are next-year forecasts, as well as current year data, five-year forecasts and historical context going back one year and five years. <BR><BR>Access the latest top-line data, highlighting: 
<LI>Return on Marketing Investment 
<LI>DM Advertising Expenditures 
<LI>DM-Driven Sales 
<LI>DM-Driven Employment 
<LI>DM Impacts by State and by Industry 
<LI>Plus, Brand New Content! In the 2009-10 Edition, the Power of Direct includes for the first time Mobile Marketing and breaks down internet marketing into 5 channels. As a result, the report slices data along: Data is broken down by channel, industry, and business model including: 15 major channels: 
<LI>Direct mail (Non-catalog) 
<LI>Direct mail (Catalog) 
<LI>Internet Display Advertising 
<LI>Search Engine Marketing 
<LI>Social Networkng sites 
<LI>Internet (Other) 
<LI>Direct Response Television 
<LI>Direct Response Radio 
<LI>Direct Response Magazines 
<LI>Direct Response Newspapers 
<LI>Direct Response Insert Media 
<LI>Other 52 major industry groupings 51 geographic regions 4 intended purpose categories: 
<LI>Direct order 
<LI>Lead generation 
<LI>Retail purchase 
<LI>Fundraising 2 major markets: <BR>Business-to-Consumer <BR>Business-to-Busines</LI> Power of Direct Marketing: ROI, Sales, Expenditures, and Employment in the US, 2009-2010 Edition

Available as a PDF.

In these challenging economic times, get access to powerful statistical evidence to fortify your decisions and justify your expenditures!

The Power of Direct Marketing provides top-line comprehensive analyses and forecasts from the DMA/Global Insight economic model on the impact of direct marketing across all industries and sectors